Sometimes, rejection from a top college doesn’t come down to your grades or accomplishments—it comes down to your tone, your intentions, and how you make the admissions committee feel about your presence on campus. A case in point? Zach Yadegari, the 18-year-old founder of Cal AI, whose recent personal statement sparked a wildfire of debate online. Despite his impressive resume, his essay showcased exactly why some brilliant candidates are still turned down by top schools.
Let’s be clear—Zach’s essay wasn’t poorly written in the traditional sense. In fact, it read like a confident, well-articulated startup pitch. But therein lies the problem: it was a pitch, not a personal statement. Instead of answering the core questions admissions officers care about—Why college? Why this school? How will you contribute to the community?—the essay doubled down on why he didn’t need college at all. It painted a picture of a student who might see college as a vanity badge or a networking playground rather than a place for genuine growth.
The essay opened with the line, “I’ll never go to college”—a provocative hook, but one that raises red flags. It immediately cast doubt on his commitment to the academic journey and instead positioned higher education as a fallback option or stepping stone to fame. It’s a risky narrative. Admissions committees want to admit students who will thrive in their environment—not ones who are likely to drop out after a semester and chase the next startup unicorn headline.
Another key issue? The tone of the essay. Many readers pointed out that it came off as arrogant, even braggadocious. The story focused heavily on Zach’s successes, his company’s ARR, and how he outgrew traditional systems. But it failed to show vulnerability, humility, or curiosity—the human qualities that make a person relatable in a community setting. There was little effort to explore how his unique journey would benefit others in the classroom, or how the college would shape him in return.
Admissions officers are not gatekeepers of talent—they’re curators of a campus culture. They want students who will engage, collaborate, and uplift their peers. When an applicant uses the essay to glorify independence to the point of dismissing the value of education, it sends the wrong signal. It suggests a lack of alignment with the school’s mission and culture.
Zach’s statement also leaned heavily on “startup fairytale” tropes—high revenue numbers, age-defying success, anti-establishment messaging—all of which made it feel more like a press release than a personal narrative. In fact, some even speculated parts of it might have been AI-generated due to the formulaic sequence. Phrases like “with every fiber of my being” felt overwritten and lacked authenticity. In trying to sound profound, it ended up sounding performative.
At the end of the day, a college essay isn’t just about telling your story—it’s about telling the right parts of your story, framed in a way that demonstrates your growth, goals, and genuine interest in joining an academic community. It’s not a place to flaunt success or settle scores with the education system. It’s a place to be human.
So, if you’re applying to college, ask yourself:
- Am I showing curiosity and a willingness to learn?
- Do I make a clear case for why I want to attend this school?
- Do I explain how I’ll contribute to and grow from the college experience?
- Am I showing who I am beyond my achievements?
Zach’s story is a powerful reminder that success in the real world doesn’t automatically translate into acceptance in the academic one. But rejection doesn’t mean failure—it means there’s room for deeper reflection. And that next chapter? It’s still wide open.
Great message! Here’s a refined and polished version of your pitch to make it even more professional and compelling:
If you’re aiming for top-tier colleges and need help building a standout extracurricular profile or want personalized career counselling services, I offer 1:1 consulting.
Reach out at www.ConsultVineet.com or email me at vineet@consultvineet.com to get started.
